Nick Mamatas (nihilistic_kid) wrote,
Nick Mamatas

When is a science fiction writer not a science fiction writer?

Over at, the person who writes their Genre in the Mainstream column—that is, the column which seeks to claim writers such as Brautigan and Millhauser as writers of the fantastic—has this to say about the fiction selections in this week's New Yorker, which is the science fiction issue:

But none of them are actually science fiction or fantasy writers...the lack of inclusion of an actual honest-to-goodness science fiction (or fantasy!) writer made me feel like we weren’t getting a fair shake.

Now, it seems to me that someone who writes a piece of science fiction or fantasy and gets it published is a science fiction/fantasy writer, at least at that moment. In this week's New Yorker is also Jonathan Lethem, who has had novels published by Tor Books, and stories in Omni, The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction, one of the Starlight anthologies, etc. So even if "science fiction writer" now simply means "someone published by a science fiction publisher",'s columnist is wrong. Clearly, something else is meant by reading a work of science fiction and declaring its author not a science fiction writer. But what could be meant? You tell me!

Poll #1843971 Why Aren't The People In the SF Issue of the New Yorker SF writers

There's something different about these people...

lack of visibile stink lines coming off their bodies
not one of them was ever Guest of Honor at Skiffycon, down at the airport Ramada
their stories are too well-written, seem faggy
all fail to claim victim status as geeks; must therefore be "Cool Kid" oppressors
Junot Diaz works at MIT, where no self-respecting science fiction writer would ever be seen
not one story about overweight libertarian supermen saving the universe from the Insecto-Negroids of Sector 7G-Alpha
fifth-columnist Nick Mamatas agitating on behalf of the New Yorker; brain parasites at work somehow
I get nothing but form rejections from the magazine and these people get in! Conspiracy!!!
I've never heard of these people because I don't read very much.
it's just not a science fiction magazine if there aren't any space whales getting raped on the cover

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
← Ctrl ← Alt
Ctrl → Alt →
← Ctrl ← Alt
Ctrl → Alt →